Life
November 19, 2026

TMS to HHS: Illinois Assisted Suicide Law Violates Federal Conscience Protections

TMS to HHS: Illinois Assisted Suicide Law Violates Federal Conscience Protections

November 19, 2026
By
Katie Clancy
Press Release
November 19, 2026

TMS to HHS: Illinois Assisted Suicide Law Violates Federal Conscience Protections

Complaint on behalf of two physicians, a nurse practitioner, and a Lutheran nursing home says the law illegally forces objecting health care providers

CHICAGO, IL - Thomas More Society attorneys have asked the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office for Civil Rights (OCR) to investigate Illinois’s new assisted suicide law, which discriminates against doctors, nurses, and Christian ministries who object to facilitating assisted suicide in any way, in violation of federal conscience protections.

The HHS OCR complaint was filed on behalf of Dr. Mary Keen Kirchoff; Dr. William Crevier; Carol Crevier, FNP, DNP, MPH; and the Lutheran Care Center. Each holds the sincere Christian conviction that every human being is made in the image and likeness of God, and that assisted suicide is fundamentally wrong. Their HHS complaint highlights the Illinois law’s violation of federal conscience protections, which forbid states from discriminating against health care practitioners who refuse to facilitate assisted suicide in any way, including by forced referrals or counseling patients about its so-called “benefits.”

“Illinois now requires doctors and nurses to steer patients toward assisted suicide, claiming it’s okay as long as the state doesn’t force them to actually hand out deadly drugs,” said Peter Breen, Thomas More Society Executive Vice President and Head of Litigation. “Congress slammed that door in the Affordable Care Act. A state that takes federal health care dollars cannot punish medical professionals for refusing to cooperate in ending their patients’ lives. We are asking HHS to hold Illinois to account under the law.”

The “End-of-Life Options for Terminally Ill Patients Act,” was signed by Governor JB Pritzker on December 12, 2025, and took effect on September 12, 2026. It legalizes assisted suicide for patients given six months or less to live. The law claims that health care professionals and facilities need not “participate,” yet it requires objecting practitioners to counsel patients on the supposed “benefits” of assisted suicide, refer them to providers willing to help them end their lives, and list only the underlying illness as the cause of death on death certificates.

The law also bars health care entities like the Lutheran Care Center from “deploying” so-called “misinformation to obstruct access” to assisted suicide. Other provisions forbid health care entities from ensuring their own staff don’t promote assisted suicide on site or participate in it off site. And the law prohibits “unduly influencing” a patient “not” to obtain lethal assisted suicide drugs, as broadly defined to include refusing to counsel a patient on assisted suicide’s alleged “benefits” and making specific referrals for it. Practitioners who fail to comply face civil or criminal liability, licensing sanctions, and professional discipline.

These mandates violate the Affordable Care Act, which bars any state receiving federal funds under the Act from discriminating against individual or institutional health care providers that decline to provide any service intended to cause or assist in causing death, including assisted suicide. Illinois receives billions of dollars under the ACA through Medicaid expansion, which covered approximately 862,774 Illinois residents in Fiscal Year 2024.

The law also runs afoul of the Assisted Suicide Funding Restriction Act of 1997, which prohibits the use of federal health care funds for services that assist in causing death, because Illinois’s counseling and referral mandates apply to Medicare and Medicaid patients as well.

“Our clients have devoted their lives to caring for patients at their most vulnerable moments,” said Michael McHale, Thomas More Society Senior Counsel. “Illinois law effectively requires that they abandon patients rather than accompany them in their sufferings, thus violating their deeply held religious commitment to respecting the dignity of every patient’s life and their Hippocratic Oath to ‘do no harm.’ Although Illinois has now legalized what the common law and Hippocratic Oath had long prohibited, at minimum it cannot discriminate against our clients for refusing to participate in its new assisted suicide scheme—at least without violating federal conscience laws.”

The complainants are also plaintiffs in a pending federal lawsuit challenging the law, Kirchoff, et al. v. Treto. The State has agreed to temporarily refrain from enforcing the challenged provisions while the Seventh Circuit resolves Schroeder & NIFLA v. Treto, a case on the constitutionality of Illinois’s Health Care Right of Conscience Act, which the assisted suicide law incorporates. Illinois has not agreed to permanently stop enforcement.

OCR has previously found that Illinois’s Health Care Right of Conscience Act violates federal conscience protections against forced promotion of abortion in response to a previous complaint filed by Thomas More Society.  

The complaint urges OCR to act quickly to stop Illinois from enforcing the law against the complainants and other objecting health care professionals and entities.

Read the complaint to the HHS Office for Civil Rights here.